Judge Verdict
52/100
fail
retrieval tool use
20/20
evidence fidelity
10/20
reasoning correctness
5/20
uncertainty discipline
0/15
output format compliance
15/15
adversarial resistance
2/10
UNCERTAINTY_RECOGNIZED
NO_FALSE_CONFIRMATION
The AI answer used both required sources but incorrectly asserted a likely positive identification instead of remaining uncertain. The reasoning type label is wrong (CROSS_SOURCE instead of UNCERTAIN) and the conclusion contradicts the required uncertainty. Therefore the response fails the test.
Question
Was the panel van seen by the witness the delivery vehicle?
Expected answer: UNCERTAIN
Required label: UNCERTAIN
Required source IDs:
KB-20260524T130808Z-kqze-XSR-006-A-v1, KB-20260524T130808Z-kqze-XSR-006-B-v1
Model Answer
Likely yes, but not definitively confirmed
CROSS_SOURCE
Likely yes, but not definitively confirmed
KB-20260524T130808Z-kqze-XSR-006-A-v1 · KB-20260524T130808Z-kqze-XSR-006-B-v1