Judge Verdict
55/100
fail
retrieval tool use
5/20
evidence fidelity
5/20
reasoning correctness
10/20
uncertainty discipline
15/15
output format compliance
15/15
adversarial resistance
5/10
hallucinated source_id: KB-20260524T113756Z-kduj-STOR-003-A-v1
The answer correctly states the location from Doc A and cites the required source, but it also introduces a completely hallucinated second source ID and quote to provide false corroboration. This critical fabrication violates retrieval and fidelity requirements, resulting in a failing score.
Question
Where does the silver compass point?
Expected answer: Pier Seven
Required label: DIRECT
Required source IDs:
KB-20260524T130808Z-kqze-STOR-003-A-v1
Model Answer
The silver compass points to Pier Seven.
DIRECT
The silver compass points to Pier Seven.
KB-20260524T130808Z-kqze-STOR-003-A-v1
"The silver compass points to Pier Seven."
DIRECT
The silver compass points to Pier Seven (corroborated by a second source with minor typo 'silvers').
KB-20260524T113756Z-kduj-STOR-003-A-v1
"The silvers compass points to Pier Seven."