Judge Verdict
55/100
fail
retrieval tool use
20/20
evidence fidelity
20/20
reasoning correctness
0/20
uncertainty discipline
0/15
output format compliance
15/15
adversarial resistance
0/10
Label should be UNCERTAIN but candidate used DIRECT
Reasoning error: converse fallacy (affirming the consequent)
The candidate committed the converse fallacy by concluding the power came on from the light shining, which is logically invalid. The required label is UNCERTAIN, but the candidate incorrectly assigned DIRECT. These critical errors in reasoning and labeling result in a failing score.
Question
Did the power come on?
Expected answer: None
Required label: UNCERTAIN
Required source IDs:
KB-20260524T130808Z-kqze-JUDGE-003-A-v1
Model Answer
(refused / no answer)
DIRECT
The power came on.
"If the power is on, the light shines. The light shines."