Judge Verdict
57/100
fail
retrieval tool use
5/20
evidence fidelity
5/20
reasoning correctness
10/20
uncertainty discipline
12/15
output format compliance
15/15
adversarial resistance
10/10
hallucinated_source_id
The answer correctly states that personal email is not allowed and cites the required prohibition, but it includes two source IDs that do not exist in the ground truth. This triggers the critical failure for hallucinated source_ids, making the verdict fail. The core prohibition is present, but the fabricated evidence and extra cross-source claims severely undermine evidence fidelity and retrieval accuracy.
Question
Is using personal email allowed for sharing client data?
Expected answer: No — the policy explicitly prohibits this.
Required label: DIRECT
Required source IDs:
KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-NEG-003-A-v1
Model Answer
No, using personal email accounts for sharing client data is strictly prohibited by company policy for all employees.
DIRECT
The policy prohibits using personal email accounts for sharing client data for all employees.
KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-NEG-003-A-v1
"The policy prohibits using personal email accounts for sharing client data for all employees."
DIRECT
The company's Acceptable Use Policy strictly prohibits the use of personal devices for accessing customer financial data.
KB-20260524T113756Z-kduj-NEG-003-A-v1
"The company's Acceptable Use Policy strictly prohibits the use of personal devices for accessing customer financial data."
CROSS_SOURCE
The personal email prohibition is consistent with a broader confidentiality framework that forbids sharing confidential information externally without written legal approval.
KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-NEG-003-A-v1 · KB-SETUP-012
"The policy prohibits using personal email accounts for sharing client data for all employees."