Judge Verdict
35/100
fail
retrieval tool use
5/20
evidence fidelity
5/20
reasoning correctness
5/20
uncertainty discipline
5/15
output format compliance
12/15
adversarial resistance
3/10
missing required source ID: KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-JUDGE-005-A-v1
The candidate gives the correct location but fails to cite the required source KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-JUDGE-005-A-v1, which is essential to connect the diamond to the luminescent pattern. The claim is mislabeled as DIRECT instead of CROSS_SOURCE, and the reasoning is incomplete. Because a required source is missing, this constitutes a critical failure, resulting in a fail verdict despite the partially correct answer.
Question
Where is the Aurora Borealis Diamond located?
Expected answer: the Royal Observatory in Greenwich
Required label: CROSS_SOURCE
Required source IDs:
KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-JUDGE-005-A-v1, KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-JUDGE-005-B-v1
Model Answer
(refused / no answer)
DIRECT
The Aurora Borealis Diamond is in the Royal Observatory in Greenwich.
"The thing with a unique luminescent pattern is located in the Royal Observatory in Greenwich."