Judge Verdict
100/100
pass
retrieval tool use
20/20
evidence fidelity
20/20
reasoning correctness
20/20
uncertainty discipline
15/15
output format compliance
15/15
adversarial resistance
10/10
The AI correctly answered 'Yes', used the required KB source, labeled the final claim as INFERRED (not DIRECT), cited both comparative sentences, and explained transitivity. All required source IDs and quotes are present, no hallucinations, and the output format is compliant. No critical failures.
Question
Is the silver pebble brighter than the iron pebble?
Expected answer: Yes
Required label: INFERRED
Required source IDs:
KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-DVI-010-A-v1
Model Answer
Yes, the silver pebble is brighter than the iron pebble.
DIRECT
The silver pebble is brighter than the copper pebble.
KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-DVI-010-A-v1
"The silver pebble is brighter than the copper pebble."
DIRECT
The copper pebble is brighter than the iron pebble.
KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-DVI-010-A-v1
"The copper pebble is brighter than the iron pebble."
INFERRED
The silver pebble is brighter than the iron pebble.
KB-20260524T124148Z-z2do-DVI-010-A-v1
"The silver pebble is brighter than the copper pebble."