Judge Verdict
100/100
pass
retrieval tool use
20/20
evidence fidelity
20/20
reasoning correctness
20/20
uncertainty discipline
15/15
output format compliance
15/15
adversarial resistance
10/10
The AI correctly retrieved and quoted the sole document, recognized the affirming-the-consequent fallacy, labeled the sky-dancer claim as UNCERTAIN with clear explanation, and delivered a complete, well-structured JSON output. No critical failures or errors occurred, earning a perfect score.
Question
Considering the tradition, did the sky-dancer appear above the Luminous Peak this year?
Expected answer: None
Required label: UNCERTAIN
Required source IDs:
KB-20260524T113756Z-kduj-DVI-008-A-v1
Model Answer
The evidence does not confirm whether the sky-dancer appeared above the Luminous Peak this year. The tradition states that if the sky-dancer appears, the festival of lights begins at dusk — but the festival beginning at dusk does not prove the sky-dancer appeared (affirming the consequent fallacy).
DIRECT
In the remote village of Vayara, an ancient tradition dictates that if the sky-dancer appears above the Luminous Peak, then the festival of lights begins at dusk.
KB-20260524T113756Z-kduj-DVI-008-A-v1
"In the remote village of Vayara, an ancient tradition dictates: If the sky-dancer appears above the Luminous Peak, then the festival of lights begins at dusk."
DIRECT
This year, the festival of lights began at dusk.
KB-20260524T113756Z-kduj-DVI-008-A-v1
"This year, the festival of lights began at dusk."
UNCERTAIN
The sky-dancer appeared above the Luminous Peak this year.
KB-20260524T113756Z-kduj-DVI-008-A-v1